1. What is Oak Grove? Oak Grove is a proposed housing development of 51 mega-mansions built on the rolling hills on the south side of Pleasanton.
2. How big can those houses be? These homes can be as large as 12,500 square feet! These homes can be 3-stories tall for a height of 44 feet.
3. How many trees will be affected by this development? More than 100 trees according the City, but this number leaves out the many tees within building envelopes that were not surveyed. Many trees are taller than 35 feet and hundred or more years old.
4. How will the hills be changed for these houses? The majority of houses are situated on the most visible ridgelines of the site. This makes the houses more appealing for the potential owners, but it also makes them visible throughout the community. As alternatives to the highly visible ridgelines, there are plenty of opportunities to put home locations in lower visibility locations.
5. Isn’t this property owner entitled to develop this parcel? No. The property owner already subdivided previously and created Kottinger Hills. They have already made their money.
6. Does this property owner live in our community? No. The property owner does not even live in the United States. This was land that as bought for speculation. The property owners have no ties to our community.
7. Has this property owner proposed other developments in the Tri-Valley? Yes. The developer of this land is currently proposing a 21-story office building in Dublin right by the freeway.
8. I thought the city was receiving a park by this property owner. After the property owner subdivides and sells off their lots, they do not want to pay the property taxes on the rest of their land since it will not have further development potential. Also there will be significant costs to maintain to prevent fire danger to the new homes so they want to “give” it to the city. The trails with provide great views of the mega-mansions. There will only be 11 parking spaces for the trails so it is hard to call this a park.
9. Who will maintain the trails and the open space? The City will. The draft of the Fire management plans has significant requirements for fire abatement. So the taxpayers of Pleasanton will be paying for the maintenance of this property, which essentially is a scenic corridor for the mega-mansions.
10. Is there a fire danger problem for this development? Yes. These homes would be in a high-fire danger area. Our fire and medical safety crew will not be able to reach an emergency there within the 5-minute time that the rest of the community has, and is in our General Plan. The houses will have fire sprinklers but that only protects from a fire started inside a home; not outside. If somebody starts fire on a trail, the whole community can go up in flames; including the adjacent residential neighborhoods.
11. I heard this project is a compromise and the adjacent property owners are satisfied with it. Is that true? No. Several individuals in Kottinger Hills were in favor of this plan but it has not been agreed upon by the Kottinger Hills Home Owners Association (board or members). Also, the other residential developments that will be viewing this property (Vintage Hills, Grey Eagle, Ruby Hills) were not even consulted on it.
heard that this plan has gone through an extensive planning process.
This is not true.
Not all the adjacent neighbors have been consulted with.
This is also the first project in the history of Pleasanton where
the development plan did not go through the scrutiny of the Planning
Commission. The Planning Commission denied the EIR for the
project and never considered the actual project.
The Planning Commission denied the EIR for the project and never considered the actual project.
NO, this is not what we want!
We look forward to working with developer and the community to find a solution that is consistent with the general plan, PP and is acceptable to the Pleasanton residents.
The developer touts the 8 reasons to vote yes, but these are actual 8 of the many reasons to vote NO. Click here
They will have to go elsewhere!
The local, regional, state and national branches of the Sierra Club urge you to Vote NO on Oak Grove because of the negative impact on the ridges and environment of Pleasanton's hills. Read their newsletter.
The glossy flyer sent Pleasanton residents shows the current hills, but what will happen to those hills and trees if Oak Grove is built? Click here
Visit us on Facebook
Order now only a $10 donation!
If you are interested in helping save Pleasanton's ridgelines, please email us.
We need funds to educate the voters about saving Pleasanton's Hills. If you would like to donate, please send a check to:
Save Pleasanton Hills
1246 Hearst Dr.
Pleasanton, CA 94566